Friday, April 15, 2011
The Raconteur [noun: a person skilled in narrating stories and anecdotes]
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
The Dreamers...
An Exercise in Passion
Attraction
And as we walked barefoot along the stretch of dew-laden greens it became increasingly clear to me that it was meant to be. Not because she could finish my sentences; not because I, for once, didn’t feel rushed—but because the tip of her nose jiggled from the tiny reverberations that emanated from her precious mouth when she laughed.
Yes, she was beautiful.
So when the dew, buffeted upwards in a fine sprinkle as she dragged her tiny feet through the soaking grass, started landing on my ankles, there was only one thing which had to be said.
“Let’s sit”, I suggested.
As the two of us planted ourselves upon a conveniently dry mound, I was aware that conversation, too, was about to run dry. The wet muddiness trickling down between the toes began to solidify into an immobile crust.
Not a word did she say.
While she stared emptily into the vast, still starry emptiness above us and I became conscious of an intrusion into our envelope of serenity – a rather large black ant struggling to overcome the formidable difficulties presented by the mud-stained smoothness of her legs - my mind flirted temporarily with the idea of making small talk. But there was a wonder in her eyes just then – a wonder which I decided not to dilute with banalities.
The world around us had dissolved in a darkness redeemed only by the pale efforts of the night sky and our conversation had, for hours, tossed and turned with glee in the delights of open-endedness. Nothing was to be judged as the world was blanketed by the night; nothing was to be evaluated by entrenched moral standards. We skirmished with morality; teetered on the brink of irreverence. The night was replete with thrilling possibilities and unforeseen directions.
Down with irrational reverence, I had suddenly decided during our walk as I dropped the bulky text book I was lugging around down to the grass and, symbolically, stepped on it with gay abandon in a moment of pulsating liberation. She watched in disapproval and disbelief as the blades of mud-coated moist grass sticking to my feet were dislodged by the pristine whiteness of the book’s cover and adorned, if unwillingly, the resounding imprint I had left behind. Then, as if suddenly succumbing to the theme of undaunted excess which underscored the night, she submitted to a volley of soft laughter.
And the tip of her nose jiggled.
If only the Sun kept away.
She emerged once more from the reverie she was immersed in and looked straight at me. Her eyes were a shade of brown resembling the crust which was now ensconced in the recesses between her toes- the residue left behind by a torrent of uninhibited conversation. Unable to meet my gaze, her eyelids drooped concealing the caramel brown within. The struggling ant now drew her attention.
I watched as her face condensed into a beatific smile.
I watched as she gently allowed the tiny creature into the cusp of her right palm and placed it back on the ground, as if in acknowledgement of its travails.
I watched as she simultaneously pushed back a strand of her dark, wavy hair behind her ears.
I watched….
Yes, she was beautiful.
Expression
And then it occurred to me that maybe, just maybe, all the charm emanated from the rusty round table and the rickety plastic chairs.
Her legs betrayed a restlessness as they rose and fell rhythmically; the tip of her fingers gently making indentations in the melted mass of sinful chocolate lying seductively at the centre of the crimson table. Slowly, she pushed the disfigured mound of brown sweetness towards me inviting me to succumb to its addictive pleasures. I knew then that the time had come. All hesitation evanesced in that one loaded gesture.
But she just couldn’t look me in the eye that night.
The nerve-endings in her neck pounded delicately in anticipation. The paper cup carrying her ice-tea quivered as the rusty round table rocked up and down from the frantic motion of her legs, sending ripples across the reflection of the moon which floated on the surface. The moon was a perfect crescent, waiting to be consummated into rotundity.
Any moment now.
When my hand inched forward to meet her fingertips, I could feel her pulse, muffled by the syrupy, brown coating of chocolate. Whether it was a hint of sparkle in her eyes that I noticed just then or the light from the night sky bouncing off the silver foil of wrapper – I cannot for certain say.
And then in happened.
Involuntarily, feelings transfigured into words and words, in search of direction, coalesced into a sentence. And drenched in the charm of the humid summer air, it rushed to the dry haven of her ears, watched over by her long, untamed, dark locks.
“So I guess then it wouldn’t be such a bad idea if we were to….”
The rhythmic motion of her legs dissipated into a placid calm. I waited for a response which I knew was not forthcoming- at least not right away.
Because she just couldn’t look me in the eye that night.
Consummation
And I wondered how the light from the street lamp, tempered into a soft glow by the thick dirty-green canopy in its way, failed to wake her up.
The smooth roundness of her head rested gently on the concrete pavement. Strands of her hair rebelled from the bun they were tied to and hung loosely from the edge of the pavement, their tips gently kissing the film of dust on the road below.
There was a certain serenity about her features - an air of submission in the faint tremor in her lower jaw, which only I knew was a smile. As I knelt closer to run my fingers through her hair, I inhaled the bittersweet smell of vodka still lingering in her breath.
We could still hear the stifled sound of music coming from within.
Placing my hand on her lower back, I lifted her torso. I pressed the bottle of mango nectar against her lips in an effort to revive her. Spurned by her lips, streams of the syrup began trickling down her neckline leaving stains of pale yellow in their trail. A drop remained, hanging menacingly from her lower lip, and I smothered it with my index finger.
Eyes still closed, she put her arm around my neck and rested her head on my chest. Then, lifting one leg, she planted it on my thighs. Soon she was in my arms – all of her.
I gazed down at the little bundle of beauty that I now held and wondered if I ever wanted her intoxication to subside. With her limp fingers she feebly tugged at the ends of my sleeve. Raising a hand slowly, she gingerly probed the thin wall of emptiness between us till the tip of her fingers found my forehead. After fiddling momentarily with a blade of my hair soaked in sweat, she began to slide her fingers down my face. I closed my eyes as Softness itself caressed my eyes; the tip of my nose; the dryness of my lips; the unshaven roughness of my chin.
Laboriously, her eyelids started picking themselves up as if to confirm the map that her fingertips had traced out. Semi-open brown eyes stared at me with the combination of curiosity, amazement and vulnerability of a baby, fresh from the womb.
As I leaned over to explore the depths of her beauty, her lips parted and eyelids closed again; decisively, this time.
Her breathing grew heavier; faster; noisier.
Until, we could no longer hear the stifled sound of music from within.
Hurt
I bent down to disentangle the formidable knot in the laces of my shoes with my numb fingers and failed miserably. Like coarse ropes of jute, they grazed my fingers, leaving jagged strands of fibre sticking out from my nails. Placing the pointed tip of one shoe on the heal of the other, I proceeded to unceremoniously strip my feet. After violently rolling over a few times, they finally settled in a clumsy heap next to the barbed wire entrance to the fields.
My first steps on the frosty greens were the most difficult. Seasons had passed me by; seasons had passed us by. The moist muddiness of summer had abandoned us, replaced by a frigid, dry hostility. As I stepped on the mound where we had had our first rendezvous, the warmth of memories was brutally disrupted by the wave of cold that assaulted my bare feet. The mound stood before me today a hardened cube of ice.
In a foolhardy display, a black ant came in my way, perhaps expecting graciousness again. Inadvertently, I stepped on it. I wanted to look back and see if it had survived; I wanted to allow it gently into the cusps of my palm and deliver it to warmth and safety. But there was no warmth to be found; no graciousness to scatter to the poor creature.
So, I trudged along, alone, in the biting cold.
The rusty round table and the rickety plastic chair were barely discernible, being consumed ruthlessly by the dense cover of fog. I paused to light my first cigarette in ten years. The smoke billowing from the burning tobacco mingled with the fog and eventually became one with it, leaving no trace behind – apart from the stench of tobacco.
The table had been withered into submission by the elements. Its hot crimson red colour had paled, eaten into, for years, by the marauding army of rust. Instinctively, my index finger reached out to touch the crusty surface of the table which left behind a stain of powdery brown on my skin; an all too familiar shade of brown, only bereft of the inviting smell of dark chocolate.
In the distance, stood a lonely street lamp – the street lamp. Cold from desuetude, it peered over the yellow, flaccid leaves and the barren stretch of concrete pavement below. As I walked the pavement once more, the heels of my feet crushed the soft chunks of gravel which lay littered into a fine powder. Trickling over the edge of the pavement, it joined the film of dust on the road, burying beneath it an orphaned strand of dark hair brought in, perhaps, by the stinging breeze. It struggled for a while to extricate itself from the pile, twisting and turning wildly in the wind. And then, emphatically, it managed to break free.
Away it flew to the south, and I could only watch.
I was aware of a sharp pain – a little drop of blood in the recesses of my toes, from a tiny splinter I had probably picked up along the way. It was cold. Far away, I could see the outline of the clumsy heap of my shoes I had left behind.
I lit my second cigarette in ten years.
And I trudged along, alone, in the biting cold.
Permanence
And I saw her again.
Amidst the deafening explosions of hand grenades, the clatter of empty cartridges on the glittering white marble tiling, the panic ridden din of the helpless Saturday night shoppers and the pungent odour from the rising fumes of smoke, I caught a glimpse of the woman I loved.
There she was: brown eyes; dark wavy hair; precious little mouth – all of her. Despite the thick veil of haze, I could see that she was still as beautiful as the girl I once held in my arms during a vodka-heavy night, ten years ago. She was on her knees. Her toes supported her tiny feet on the pristine white floor, stained in shades of hot crimson red; her shoes, dislodged from her feet, lay sprawled in a clumsy heap.
I stepped closer.
The air was heavy with the stench of gunpowder and it made her cough violently. The tears rolling down her face from her reddened eyes rushed to her parted lips. Spurned by her lips, they trickled down her tender neckline leaving behind a moist trail.
With her bloody hands she tried to stop the flow of blood oozing out from the wounds of the man lying at her feet- his chest perforated by three, maybe four, rounds of fire. A strand of her long, dark hair hung loosely down her shoulders and made a gentle indentation on a puddle of blood on the floor. She was sobbing uncontrollably, begging for help.
And the tip of her nose jiggled.
Somewhere, from within one of the stores played a Beethoven Symphony. The music tried to lend some serenity but was overpowered by the discordant notes of cartridges showering down on the marble floor.
And then she saw me.
Just then, I could see in those caramel brown eyes, a grotesque communion of fear, shock, disbelief and what I hoped was a smattering of guilt.
She looked alternately at me and the rifle that I was pointing at her.
There was the faint tremor in her lower jaw which only I knew to be a smile. I moved closer. The icy barrel of my rifle now pressed against her collar bone. A wave of cold ran through her body and her slender torso convulsed involuntarily. She looked up at me. I tried to keep my gaze fixed on her eyes for the answers to all my questions. But a violent gust from an explosion nearby scattered her hair over her face, concealing the caramel brown within.
We were instructed to kill all in sight. I didn’t have much time- neither did the wounded man whose blood smeared hand she still held. There was plenty I had to say to her but only one thing I could say right then; the only thing which mattered.
‘Do you love me?’ I hissed slowly, making certain that each word impaled her being.
She looked alternately at me and the rifle that I was pointing at her.
Finally, she looked straight at me and blinked suggestively. I lowered my rifle bent down, grabbed her by the hair and kissed her mouth; my first kiss in ten years. A teardrop hung menacingly from her lower lip. As I reached out to smother it, it fell onto a ring she now wore – her wedding ring. We had kissed while her husband lay dying.
‘Down with irrational reverence’, I said.
She let out a feeble, mirthless chuckle.
As I proceeded to kiss her again, her hair scattered over her face again, by what I thought was …. It didn’t matter anymore. She was shot in the head.
She stared dreamily into the distance as I held her in my arms once more. The Symphony still meandered about, trying to pacify. Somehow, she managed to give me a parting gift. Her final words to me.
“Help him”.
She was still holding his hands. For a few seconds, she continued staring into emptiness.
Until, she could no longer hear the sound of music from within.
The 8:15
There is a rather prominent school of thought which advocates the notion that all human beings choose the path of least resistance. Of course, there are always people who hate schools of any manner. These are people who would go to considerable lengths to disprove established theories about the human psyche. Perhaps they take umbrage to the idea of them being figured out. There is, however, another branch of this clan which seems to have found an easier way around this predicament. Their modus operandi is to gradually distance themselves from the very crowd which is under the constant scanner of psycho analysis. This is akin to a self inflicted mutation, though in a very non intrusive way. Yet, another prominent clan which, by the looks of it, is multiplying like rabbits is the one which neither understands nor could care less about the aforementioned drivel. And then there was Luke.
See, the thing was that Luke was never particularly fond of his bus journeys to his place of employment. Some people revel in the romanticism involved in the imagery of them starting, cappuccino in hand, a fresh working day. And it would not be too much of a stretch to imagine a little sparkling blue bus as the backdrop for this lush visual. This tale, however, is about Luke. These romantic bus commuters may have figured in the story had Luke boarded the 8:15 that morning. Which brings me back to the fact that Luke was never particularly fond of his bus journeys to his place of employment. Certain though I am that you would like to know a bit more about the nature of his employment and draw inferences about him ,this is precisely what I will not have you do. Neither would Luke, for that matter. I would like to take a moment to clarify my position in the scheme of things. My role in this little tale is that of a dispassionate chronicler of events. The only thing that I knew for certain about Luke was that he harboured a distaste for his ride to work. So how did I figure that out?
What often bothers me about smart theories is that they tend to be conspicuous by their absence when they are needed the most. It is only after the solution has reared its elusive head that they furtively crawl out of their holes. Put more simply, the mind has a propensity of approaching problems more efficiently when they cease to be problems. Or maybe its just my mind. But that is hardly my point. What I mean to say is there was nothing about Luke that would make me doubt his intentions to board the 8:15 as he stood next to me at the bus junction that morning. If I was privy to his reluctance, I would have undoubtedly searched him for the usual indicators like furrowed brows, twitching lips and similar expressions of hesitance. But people don’t notice these things, do they? Holmes did and he was fictional. The truth of the matter was more Watsonesque . Which, by the way, is a more witty way of saying that the truth of the matter was more mundane. In plain words, I knew because he told me so. With furrowed brows and with a twitch of the lips he said, “I am not particularly fond of my bus journeys to my place of employment”.
The more perceptive of you may wonder how this dispassionate chronicler came to know the name of this shabbily sketched character that he encountered at the bus junction. Ah, but therein lies the rub. It is rather difficult to know how to narrate an incident when you are not quite sure about how it panned out in the first place. Although I am positive that he was christened Luke within days of him being born, for most part of the incident he was just another face in the crowd for me. Therefore, revealing how I came to know his name would involve me revealing far more than I intend to at this stage. I don’t, however, wish to create an impression that the incident to which I allude was a long drawn out one or even, for that matter, one of life altering ramifications. Indeed, as I may have occasioned to mention before, the truth of the matter is rather Watsonesque.
The time is ripe for an analysis of the control that a seemingly innocuous cigarette exerts on the life of a man. I like smoking. Make no mistake about it. I like the smell of cigarettes. I like the smell of people who smoke cigarettes. I certainly yield to nobody in the knowledge and trivia associated with tobacco wrapped in paper. And yet, it causes me no slight perturbation. I am sure I speak for a lot of smokers when I say that stubbing out a cigarette before it burns out brings forth sentiments not dissimilar to unrequited love. Obviously, the cigarette being the spurned party bears the brunt of this sentiment. I don’t wish to imply it is actually the flame of passionate love that you extinguish when you rub your rugged shoe across its smooth, slender and smouldering body. No, that would be rather daft. Anyways, my point is, for a fleeting moment before you actually decide to stub out the thing it exerts an invisible force on your being. It is a force which I like to refer to as control. Control has an illustrious list of victims and achievements and it was, for it, the work of a moment to ensure that Luke missed the 8:15.Luke puffed away as the little sparkling blue bus spewed out some smoke of its own.
As you may have already figured out, I wasn’t exactly waiting at the bus junction to board the 8:15.Or the 8:25, for that matter. Indeed, I must confess to having no intention of commuting anywhere. Suddenly, I can feel the gaze of your attention diverted from Luke to me. Who is this dispassionate chronicler anyways? What is his story? Admittedly, I have taken the liberty of concealing myself behind the protagonist. It is not something I am ashamed of. It is a literary tool employed with a great deal of success in the past, most notably by one Dr. John.H.Watson. Nevertheless, I find it extremely difficult to move on without taking you into some sort of confidence. Watson did not and he was fictional.
Do not dismiss this tale as a culmination of an hour idled away at a local bus junction. Quite to the contrary, my life seemed to have gone into auto pilot mode. You know how they say “Stop the world and I’ll get off.”? Well, they deserve a thump on the back and a pat on the head for having succinctly described my sentiments that morning. The 8:15 had been an inseparable part of my existence for years now. The arrival of the little sparkling blue bus seemed to signify, each morning, the last independent choice that I had each day. The moment I boarded the bus, I was in the tenacious claws of control. Don’t get me wrong- I did not detest my means of livelihood. In fact, it would not be overstating it to say that I fairly enjoyed it. Nevertheless, like the cigarette that I hated stubbing out, it exerted a control on my actions. It arrested free will. And I could not live like that. At least, not that morning.
Solitude has a distinct way of going about its business. The business being, quite obviously, to eliminate the lack of itself. At times it slowly pushes you into a corner with a workman like diligence. On other occasions, its actions are precipitated by the assistance of little blue sparkling buses which seem to suck all that can move into them. The 8:15 had come and gone and when the smoke from its exhaust had cleared, Luke and I were all that remained. I don’t know if you have ever been confronted with a situation when a bloke suddenly ceases to be just another face in the crowd and you feel compelled to walk up to him and make small talk. If you had inquired of me that morning as to why I had walked up to Luke and asked him the time, I would have been at loss to answer. The question would have posed a formidable challenge. However, looking back now, I am able to propose a smart theory behind my action. The reason why Luke had ceased to be just another face in the crowd was that the crowd had now disappeared. And since I find the human connection infinitely more interesting than the spotted cat on the opposite pavement or the patterns traced out by the smoke from cigarettes, Luke became the object of my undiluted attention. You may deride my theory as mere elementary and you may be right. My position, nevertheless, on the matter is that the worth of a theory should be estimated decoupled from the time at which it was thought out. What was smart then is but elementary now. Maybe I am just making allowances for the propensity of the human mind to approach problems more efficiently when they cease to be problems. Or maybe it’s just my mind. But that’s hardly my point.
“8: 15” replied Luke curtly, his lips still engaged in passionate lip lock with the filter of the cigarette.
“Next bus isn’t until another 15 odd minutes”
“I know”
Ordinarily, there would have been precious little I could have said at this stage without sounding like a complete pest. Missing the 8:15 should have had a liberating effect on me. My sentiments, on the other hand, could be compared to the schoolboy who after having bunked classes for the first time was in need of a place to lie low. I was anxious, fidgety and in need of a conversation. It disturbed me that after all the lofty thoughts about regaining free will from the clutches of the 8:15, my free will, seemingly, wanted nothing more than the return of normalcy. It was like an expensive purchase of a football club failing to live up to the bloated expectations.
“You know, they should reserve the window seats for smokers.” I said.
Luke turned to look at me, perhaps for the first time. Although he may have caught a glimpse of me earlier, it was probably because I was obstructing the path of light reaching his eyes. He must have suddenly decided that I deserved a second look.
“And that would achieve…?”
“Well, you obviously seemed to have missed your bus.”
“And you yours.”
“You don’t know that. I could easily have been waiting for the 8:35”
“My sentiments exactly”
Ordinarily, there would have been precious little I could have said at this stage without sounding like a complete pest. But I had raised the bar once and now there was no looking back.
“So did you?” I continued shamelessly. I realize that having promised to be the dispassionate chronicler, you probably feel that I should stop judging myself. But I am not judging myself, you see. I was shameless. With a vengeance; intentionally, and with beastliness of forethought. I needed this conversation.
“Did I what?”
“Miss the bus.”
Luke let out a soft chuckle and took a deep drag from the cigarette. As he watched the ash doing an involuntary jig on the grey pavement, the chuckle condensed into an almost beatific smile. He reached into his pocket and offered me a cigarette. I have always believed that there must be an ingredient in cigarettes that stimulates bonding in general and male bonding in particular. Someday it may transpire that this ingredient also contributes to cancer. Very often, life is like that.
“I wouldn’t quite phrase it that way” said Luke.
“Well, how would you phrase it?”
“The bus missed me.”
“That’s not rephrasing. That’s….lying.” I was being argumentative. And I am not judging myself. Again.
Luke let out a second soft chuckle and lit up a second cigarette to go with it. He gently stroked his stubble with his fingernails and pretended to straighten the tie that he had obviously forgotten to wear, having lost it, perhaps, in the recesses of his cupboard together with the shaving cream and razor.
“Its Thursday, you see.” he said
“Quite so.” I replied, nonplussed.
“It’s my mid week break.”
“What sort of an employer gives you a mid week break?”
“The sort that wants to hire me anyways” he retorted.
“So you spend your off day watching people boarding buses to go to work” I suggested with a hint of unconcealed sarcasm.
“And smoking at the same time,” he replied bluntly.
“I stand corrected”
People say that it’s amazing the things one can do when one doesn’t have to look at oneself in the mirror. I guess it follows that you can confide a great deal in people when you are certain to never cross paths with them again. My ignorance about Luke was comparable only to his ignorance about me. And yet Luke, who was, by now, well into his third cigarette, was opening up fast. He was smoking even faster.
“That’s a little sadistic. I take it that you are not particularly fond of your employment?” I continued after pausing to take another drag of nicotine.
With furrowed brows and with a twitch of the lips he said, “I am not particularly fond of my bus journeys to my place of employment”. And he said it with a great deal of poignancy.
All of a sudden, the conversation seemed fraught with opportunities. I had initiated this conversation with the sole intention of steering myself away from the anxiousness that my situation had presented me with. Now, the meandering route adopted by it had, eventually, shoved me headlong into a confrontation with the same anxiety. Of course, I realized that the reasons for his dislike of the bus journey may have been more mundane than mine. However, there was something about the way the cigarette smoke brought out his grey, dreamy eyes that should have told me that he would not attribute his reluctance in boarding the 8:15 to the infernal crowd or the rising prices of gasoline. But as always, I didn’t quite think of it then.
“And it’s not because of the infernal crowd or the rising prices of gasoline,” he continued.
By now, another cluster of people had surfaced to board the 8:25.
“Right now, the only thing these people want is to board that bus and begin their day. I derive a little peace in seeing them get what they want. Is that sadistic? If I stand here long enough and see enough people beginning their day, I feel…… ahead,” said Luke. He was not so much addressing me as mouthing a soliloquy staring into empty space.
“But they have begun their day, haven’t they? You haven’t.”
“Neither have you,” was his riposte.
There was nothing to be said. And as we smokers often do when there is nothing to be said, I took another puff. A pregnant silence ensued at the end of which he suddenly turned and looked straight into my eyes. I tried to avert his penetrating gaze but it was an attempt in futility. Even now, in my most vulnerable moment, I didn’t want to be figured out. Very often, people are like that.
“Tell me something,” said Luke. “You watched the 8:15 come and leave without you. You smoked and engaged in a conversation with an utter stranger. Stretched before you now is a day with endless possibilities and limitless opportunities, without any strings attached. It’s a day when you have to do nothing and yet there is so much you can do. How do you feel?”
There was another one of those pregnant silences which was rudely aborted by a sudden buzz of activity at the junction. The 8:25 came to a screeching halt before us and the customary mad rush followed, accompanied by a generous helping of an awful din. There was only one thing left to be asked.
“What is your name?” I shouted out loud.
“Luke. The 8:25 is here. You can choose to get on it or you can choose to walk away. Either way, go begin your day.”
When the 8:25 had left and the smoke from its exhaust had cleared, I found myself standing alone at the junction. Six half-smoked cigarettes adorned the spot where Luke had been standing. The spotted cat from the opposite pavement occupied his place with the regal air of an heir and purred with lazy content.
Looking back, my mind is now pestered with doubts as to whether his name was actually Luke. Did he just over-pronounce the word look? Maybe I am just making allowances for the propensity of the human mind to approach problems more efficiently when they cease to be problems. Or maybe it’s just my mind. But that is hardly my point.
________________________________________
On knowledge,instinct and..Nietzsche!
To begin at the very beginning, true to the Socratic Method, perhaps it would be appropriate to revisit and question any assumptions we may have about the nature and inception of knowledge; only then can we really begin to make a foray into Nietzsche’s profound views on the subject. So ,as uncomfortable as it may sound , let us, for the purpose of this exposition completely disregard the view of knowledge as an object and attempt to look upon it as an event; a consequence; or even a byproduct , maybe.
Of what, you ask?
Well, in delving deeper into the matter, I would urge you to adopt a more microscopic view of the concept of knowledge. You need only to make a cursory inspection of our surroundings to appreciate the fact that nature resists complexity- behind every seemingly complex entity in space or time there is always a set of simple ideas, concepts and ingredients which are, well, for all practical purposes, indivisible. The carbohydrates are after all made of simple sugar molecules; proteins, the building block of life, are composed of amino acids; and even energy, according to the Quantum theory, is transmitted in smaller packets.
So it seems rather inevitable that a construct as complex as knowledge should, also, have its foundations in simplicity- something more in the realm of the unconscious. And Nietzsche chose to call it instinct.
Now, in order to share Nietzsche’s view of knowledge we need to introduce into this microscopic view of knowledge, an element of causality or interplay. So, consider, if you will, a rather simplistic description of the formation of a chemical compound- the atoms of individual elements interacting, sharing, exchanging and finally giving rise to a more complex third entity. In fact, if Nietzsche is to be believed, this is similar to how knowledge comes into being- a causal effect of the interplay of instincts.
Let us now attempt to reconcile Nietzsche’s view with Freudian concepts of id and ego and superego. The id component of personality represents all the primeval needs we are constantly barraged by- hunger, thirst, lust, pain etc. Our instincts , untempered by the superego, would always seek to satisfy these needs .At the very beginning , therefore, data is all there is; we are surrounded by sensory stimuli which mean nothing to us but which force us to react anyways-react instinctively, to satisfy the id.
But gradually, according to Nietzsche, the interplay of these instincts will cause the inception of knowledge, the point in time when we are able to assimilate the data into information. From a Freudian perspective, it is conceivable that this is where the superego makes its presence felt and alters decision making in accordance with the individual’s reference points. To illustrate, if a speeding truck were to be headed your way while crossing a road, you would instinctively scamper to get out of the way owing to the fight or flight response. Now if, hypothetically, this had been the first time you were ever crossing a road, the approaching truck would have been for you merely a sensory stimulus, a data you reacted to instinctively. However, says Nietzsche, with the exercise of this instinct, knowledge has been conceived- the knowledge that caution must be exercised while crossing roads.
And there in a nutshell, is my opinion on what I believe was Nietzsche’s view on knowledge and instinct. Perhaps I haven’t been entirely accurate but as Nietzsche, himself, once famously said: There are no facts, only interpretations!
Saturday, December 5, 2009
An Exercise in Dark Humour
Insouciant. I don’t know about you, but I have always liked the sound of this particular word. There is certain quality about the word that gives me the distinct impression of it being French. Not that I am familiar with the language. Not a chance. Maybe it’s just the way it makes the lips stretch outwards that appeals to me. Anyways, in my opinion, it is a word which ought to be used more often in everyday conversations. I, for one, loved incorporating it my communications, both written and oral, at the slightest of opportunities. It having transpired, however, that not many are aware of the meanings and connotations of the word, I had to sacrifice my grammatical excesses at the altar of simplicity.
So when the man sprawled out on the floor before me cried out, “Insouciant!”, you can scarcely blame me for being a little surprised. Truth be told, I was a little startled because he hadn’t spoken to me in over fifteen minutes and seeing as I was trapped in a room with him, with no other means to amuse myself, his taciturn manner came across as rather rude. But then one must make allowances for the fact that he was nursing a gun shot wound to the lower abdomen and probably had a precious few minutes to live. Even so, I expected a little more spunk.
See, the thing is that I am not one to start conversations. So while he sulked and brooded over the blood oozing out of his perforated belly, I decided to give him the silent treatment. And I gave it to him in large helpings. Eventually, I knew, that someone had to fold, and being the one who could still stand on his feet, I was fairly sanguine about my prospects in this little duel.
“Insouciant !”,he cried out again with that distant look in his eyes which is so characteristic of people nursing a gun shot wound to the abdomen. I found it poetic that my favourite word, which had fallen into desuetude, was being vouched for with such ferocity by a dying man. Maybe, long before he fell into the sordid ways that eventually led to him being shot in the abdomen, he was like any other kid who had committed word lists to memory to get admitted into colleges. Things probably didn’t work out, and now, as fate would have it, the chemical reactions in the dying brain were causing him to randomly spew out words he had forgotten when it mattered most. Or maybe it was because I was painting, at this instant, in shades of blood red, my interpretation of human bondage using a nearby twig that elegantly doubled as a paint brush. Hard to say, these things.
Ordinarily, I would have considered this to be the blood stained olive branch extended by him for want of a truce. However, the tone that he employed was rich with the insinuation that I was responsible for the position of inconvenience that he found himself in. It wasn’t as if I had drilled those bullets into him and I would definitely not take such slander lying down. Actually, technically, he was lying down. But, I suppose you get my point.
I had turned my back on him and held my plans of socialising with my fellow prisoner in abeyance until he adopted a more agreeable stance. Also, my profession had afforded me a good deal of time to study gun shot victims at close quarters and I could tell that the current subject had ,at best, another ten minutes of association with the earthly. I debated the merits of providing him with a rather bleak character appraisal when he was well into the final ten minutes of his life, most of which he would spend clutching his abdomen and accuse me of being an “insouciant”, insensitive prick. Hardly seemed worth the trouble, actually.
The little room where I was held captive was by now, with no insignificant assistance from my fellow prisoner, filled with the nauseating stench of blood and sweat. The risk of forced confinement was a part of my job description. I had always hoped, though, that those who inflicted it would have the professional courtesy to respect my privacy. Solitary confinement is the way to go, I say. Stuffing me in with another dying thug was a move calculated to remind me of the fate that awaits me. And, in my field of work, one wants as little of that as possible. This man had it coming and so did I.
The silence in the room was punctuated only by the periodic grunts and moans of my wounded adversary. I had sufficient reason to exact revenge from this man and had he not being dying so fast, I am not sure I would not have facilitated the process. Although I could appreciate the pain he was in, for I had been shot at an earlier occasion myself, I saw no reason not to make his exit unceremonious. Kick them when they are down, I say.
The colour had drained from his face and his features were contorted with the white hot pain that he was going through. The tip of his ears convulsed involuntarily.
“Chin up, buddy! What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. Even if we assume that it will kill you there is a chance that the benefit will carry forward the next time you are born. Don’t mind me saying, but you were always a bit of a wimp.” I said.
Apparently my facetious jibe did not go down too well with him for he continued to stare expressionlessly into my eyes. He was sweating profusely and the few patches of his shirt that weren’t stained red were damp with sweat.
“Kill me”, he muttered using the remnants of his life force, hoping to end the suffering.
“Too easy. Maybe someday when you are more game for a fight,” I quipped.
Almost instantly he let out a guttural roar of agony and started urinating uncontrollably into his pants.The stench was now unbearable. I picked up an old newspaper from the floor and pressed my nose against it as hard as I could without suffocating myself.
“ Help me ..please”, he shrieked in agony. He was into the final despairing moments.
Funny thing, this humanity is. Even the most immoral of men get morally outraged when denied a piece of it in their moment of desperation.
“I’d love to buddy”, I said, “but I’m in bit of a fix myself. But why don’t you just wait? They say time is a great healer. If it works, you get to live. If you don’t, we learn something new.”
I took out the pen knife that I had been hiding inside my left shoe. My escape plan hinged on its effective usage. A sudden stab to the eye followed by a manoeuvre to rid the guard of his gun ought to do the trick. But for now, I needed some quiet to think my escape through.
“See this? If you promise to stop bothering me, I can lend it to you for a while. Try not to leave too much of a mess. Consider it my good deed for the day.”
I have never prided myself on my bedside manners and it was beyond me to hold his hand while he died. Anyways, I doubt I would have got much of a grip considering how bloody they were. Handing him the pen knife, I turned around to give the man the dignity in death that he denied others in life. The sounds that I heard over the next couple of minutes painted a story of desperate suicide.
When I turned around, nothing could have prepared me for what I saw. There was no trace of a gruesome slit in the throat or a gaping cavity in the chest. He hadn’t used the pen knife. He had swallowed it. He was looking straight at me with the serenity of man who was about to rest in peace. And then with a singularly despicable smile he coughed out his final words.
“Insouciant bastard…”
Kick them when they are down, I say.
Sunday, November 22, 2009
A Bit of Freire and Oppression
Through his book entitled “Pedagogy of the Oppressed”, Paulo Freire offers us a glimpse into what he thinks it will take to bring about a socio political upheaval characterized by a complete absence of gradients in society. He envisions a world devoid of wilful subjugation of man and posits, through this book, that it is only through complete awareness of our circumstance that we can hope to effect constructive changes.
Throughout this socio-political treatise, Freire tries to reiterate “dehumanization” as both the cause and the effect of the oppression which scars our society. He adopts a micro approach towards the study of society and tries to dissect, using, at times, elementary logic and knowledge of human behaviour, individual reactions to oppression. But what lends novelty to “Pedagogy of the Oppressed” is its determination to explore the perspectives of not just the social underdogs but also of those who unleash this dehumanizing current.Objectively, dispassionately and yet with palpable intensity, Freire sets out to explore what makes the entrenched oppressor-oppressed dynamic so sturdy and resistant to change.
Freire opines that the diffusion of the oppressed into the environment of oppression blinds them to the reality of their circumstance and stifles any meaningful revolution. For us to peel away the coating of inequity and injustice smeared across the existing socio-political order and to emerge as liberated individuals , we must learn to isolate ourselves from the societal casserole which contains us and subject our roles as social actors to objective scrutiny.
Wary of hypocrisy and cowardice masquerading as “verbalism”, Freire endorses words which are a manifestation of the communion of incisive reflection and steadfast intent as an initiator of change. At the same time, he is aware that misdirected and visceral action only serves to exacerbate circumstances and obstruct the path of revolution .History is replete with instances which vindicate Freire’s reservations against what he calls “Activism”-the violent outburst of Indian freedom fighters at Chauri Chaura, to cite one.
The seeds of oppression, says Freire, are sown deep into the very heart of our education system in which there is an inherent disconnect between the teacher and the taught owing to a pedagogy which is built on the presumption of an intellectual gradient. Terming the existing approach as a “banking approach” Freire denounces it in favour of a more participative form of learning which involves a dialogue between teacher and student, shuns the pedantic and embraces the practical and creative. The purpose of education should be to stimulate independent, objective thinking which facilitates a critical and original outlook, so integral to a “radical”.
Freire goes a step further and identifies why the existing setup proves to be difficult to overthrow. The Oppressors who recognize the subjugation, make no real attempt to liberate the Oppressed in order to continue to have the opportunity to intermittently oblige them with displays of “false generosity”.
To truly empower the downtrodden, we must overcome our base urge to feel good by scattering largesse every now and then and, as a consequence, manufacturing an illusion of nobility. Empowerment results not from the odd incremental monetary or knowledge gains thrust into the hands of those who don’t know what do with it in the first place but from socially conscientizing these oppressed classes and allowing them to understand why they need what they need. Setting them on the course of a blind pursuit of one material conquest after another will merely serve to alleviate their lot without humanizing them and would set into motion the vicious cycle of the oppressed turning into the oppressor.
Which, to me, begs the question- “Just how effective is our response to the prevalent oppression?”
Sure, there are literacy programs fuelled by fund raisers in which celebrities get to walk the red carpet and revel in the glamour and glare which comes from being in the public eye. Sure, some of these funds do eventually reach NGO’s who manage to thrust a chalk and slate into the hands of impoverished kids and dilapidated elderly, and teach them to legibly scribble the 26 alphabets or count on their fingers. And then begins the prolonged self-congratulatory phase that we, the oppressors (deliberate or inadvertent), simply cannot resist. We claim to have attempted to “liberate” the under-privileged and “empowered” them. How? By teaching them to spell their names?
This myopic view of what constitutes social progress has proven to be our collective undoing. I, personally, refuse to believe that education- in its fundamental form- is the ability to write on a piece of paper, read out eloquently or the ability to summon impressive sounding managerial jargons. In its broadest definition possible, education must be the ability to assess your own little role in the infinitely large and endlessly complex scheme of things. Without that awareness, any personal goals that we define are parochial in thought and trivial in their overall consequence. Direction must be provided by a combination of social conscientization and self awareness and not by the prices of the latest tech gizmo or the trendiest outfit in the market.
Unless we are unable to, somehow, align our efforts at liberating with a broader vision and inject it with a sense of greater purpose, we will fail at making any significant inroads into the existing oppression-infested socio-political order.
Perhaps this line of thought strays into the territory of idealism. Which is perhaps why we don’t live in an ideal world.
